Upper Captiva Homes For Sale & Real Estate - 17 homes

Remarks: Rare CANAL home offered for sale on a protected canal with about 80 feet of dock possibly for larger boats. Its a very beautiful home with a reverse floor plan with the living space on the upper floor. Not a problem carrying groceries or heavy items upstairs with the newly serviced elevator. Wonderful private views to be enjoyed as one looks across the State Wildlife Preserve and out to Pine Island Sound. And the views are even better from the upper mezzanine area above the living room which could be another sleeping area. Plenty of room for guests with 3 bedrooms, a den and 3.5 bathrooms. The third full bathroom is downstairs by the screened pool. The beach is just down the road to a parking area with access to the widest beach on the island. New roof. Make an appointment to see this wonderful home.

Listing is courtesy of: Islander Realty (239-472-3000)

Listing Agent: Cheryl Bredin (239-472-3000)

Remarks: This waterfront property is a piece of paradise. Enjoy beautiful bay views from the front screened-in porch and watch the boats come and go from Safety Harbor. Relax to the sounds of the cheerful sea birds that soar over Safety Harbor and watch the dolphins swim in the bay. This meticulously maintained townhouse has gorgeous views of Safety Harbor. New roof in 2023. The master suite has an updated bathroom with walk-in shower, and there is a peaceful screened-in sitting area right off the master bedroom. Two adorable bedrooms are upstairs, with sweeping bay views from one of the upstairs bedrooms. The lower area has brand new flooring, a laundry area, a bonus refrigerator, and full golf cart garage to park your golf cart (included). The community dockage is just steps away from the front door, with additional slips available at the community wharf where you will find a fish cleaning station and plenty of docks to fish from. Also steps away from the front door is a lovely bay beach where you can launch your kayak or go fishing. Membership with Safety Harbor Club includes a community heated pool, tennis and pickle ball, private beach access with beach-front gazebo, a restaurant on the water, clubhouse, and miles of pristine, uncrowded, white sugar-sand Gulf beaches. North Captiva is an island with no roads to it, so ride the bi-hourly Island Girl ferry from Pineland Marina to North Captiva and get around the island on golf carts. This unique feature of the island makes it particularly peaceful and attractive.

Listing is courtesy of: Preferred Properties Group Inc (239-777-3113)

Listing Agent: Desiree Wilson (307-349-5017)

Remarks: This Charming Island Beach Cottage has been fully remodelled from top to bottom! Upgrades include impact-resistant windows throughout the home, Hardie-board siding, an aluminum standing seam roof with kynar finish, a redesigned kitchen, new tile flooring, and very tastefully updated bathrooms. The freshly painted tongue and groove ceilings give this home a unique old Florida character. The new fabulous custom kitchen features an oversized central island that doubles as the dining space, glistening over-the-counter sliding window, stylish open shelving, and custom shaker-style cabinetry. The main bedroom suite features a spectacular en suite bath with a walk-in shower, plus beautiful vaulted ceilings over the king bed. The secondary suite offers an entire wall of gorgeous windows, filling your views from this room with majestic palms. The accompanying en suite bath offers a custom tiled walk-in shower and a closet/dressing area. This home is ideally located only 450 feet from the beach, with access directly down the deeded road easement at the end of the sandy lane. A ground-level non-conforming bonus suite area offers one more additional sleeping room with a full bath and storage areas. Just a short golf cart ride from local restaurants, shopping, the ferry landing, and resort-style amenities. This old Florida-style cottage would make a great vacation rental, especially with the addition of a pool. If you having been looking for an old Florida style cottage close to the beach at an affordable price point, this house is a must see!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Expansive & Panoramic Gulf Views with the Beach Just Steps Away! This soaring 4 bedroom and 3 bath estate home offers Hardie board siding, aluminum railings, and impact windows. The reverse floorplan creates fantastic views from every corner of the living spaces, indoors and out. Imagine relaxing on the 2nd level porch or 3rd-floor mezzanine, gazing at the incredibly scenic coastline of Cayo Costa. The top level could be a fifth sleeping space or your favorite sunset-watching room. Custom kitchen with stainless steel appliances and formal dining nook surrounded by windows. The first-story covered screen porch has excellent gulf views from the master suite and largest guest bedroom. Heated pool and extensive deck space. Great for dining and entertaining. This property includes a nearby beachfront parcel and a deeded walkway easement for a sandy path to your private Gulf beach. A wide-view easement over the adjacent beachfront property to the west also helps to maintain your view over time. The location, number of sleeping areas, pool, and very special view give this home excellent rental potential. To complement this outstanding home, a valuable DOCK SLIP is available in the nearby boat basin for an additional price of $200k with the house. Furthermore, the adjacent beachfront lot to the west can also be available for purchase to connect this home all the way to the water.

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Adorable island cottage on beautiful North Captiva Island with classic beach style. This bungalow offers three sleeping rooms, making great use of the space. The living room and kitchen area are full of charm with tongue-and-groove wood walls, an authentic coastal retreat style. The two levels of decking are great for watching sunsets and gathering with the family.  The home is located on a valuable oversized lot, just a short stroll or golf cart ride to the nearest beach access. Plenty of room to add on or install a large pool and outdoor entertainment area. Impact windows and sliders throughout, plus new hardie-board siding. Don't miss out on the chance to affordably obtain your beach house dream goal on this one-of-a-kind island!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: This custom-built, 4-bedroom home boasts panoramic views of the harbor and sound. The property’s location offers an ideal setting for observing sunrises, and the experience of witnessing the sunrise from this perspective is truly remarkable. Meticulously crafted with attention to every detail, the spacious and luxurious residence sits directly on a navigable canal with two dock slips. The exterior features a large, covered, and screened porch that overlooks the docks and a private, heated swimming pool. Hardie board siding, a metal roof, impact windows and doors, and distinctive custom-painted Hardie plank lap siding lend an air of refined elegance. The interior is nothing short of astounding, with a custom kitchen boasting sparkling granite countertops, dark wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and teardrop light fixtures. The great room and open-concept living and dining areas are centered on the panoramic water views, allowing you to enjoy sparkling sunrises over the bay. An additional living room/den with a wet bar leads to four split bedrooms on the bedroom level. There is a bonus room, measuring no less than 100 square feet, offers ample space and currently accommodates a bunk bed, a foosball table, and an air hockey table. The potential uses for this room are limitless.. Local beaches, restaurants and shops on Upper Captiva are within a short walking distance. Make an appointment to see this awesome home.

Listing is courtesy of: Islander Realty (239-472-3000)

Listing Agent: Yvena Dervil (239-443-7574)

Remarks: Immerse yourself in the coastal charm of North Captiva Island with this beautiful townhome. From the living area and guest bedroom, you’ll enjoy lovely harbor views that are better than other current townhome offerings. The extra spacious, upgraded kitchen is a dream for anyone who loves to entertain, featuring stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a sleek tile backsplash. Elegant travertine tile flooring runs throughout the home, adding a touch of sophistication. The remodeled bathrooms are a highlight, boasting custom tile walk-in showers for a bit of everyday luxury. You'll have easy access to your boat and the club's restaurant, conveniently located just steps from the ferry landing and the townhome’s shared docks. As part of the exclusive Safety Harbor Club, you’ll have access to a range of private amenities, including a pool, tennis courts, pickleball, and private beach access. This townhome offers a perfect blend of island living and modern comfort, ideal for a laid-back lifestyle by the water.

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Welcome to "Paradise Palms" on North Captiva. A quick ferry ride gets you to a tropical paradise, leave your troubles & worries behind. Come see this beautiful turnkey home that has been professionally decorated, so it's ready immediately for your pleasure or for continued rental income. This custom home is one of the few on the island with its own private pool, located on the living level, don't have to walk downstairs to enjoy pool fun or to cook on the grill. Access straight off the kitchen, primary bedroom & one of the guest bedrooms. 3 bedrooms PLUS a private den located on its own level, easily can be used as 4th bedroom if needed. From this den, walk up to the sky deck and take in the 360' views of the Gulf of Mexico, Cayo Costa & Pine Island Sound. No paved roads, no traffic jams on this island as it's a golf cart community only. North Captiva is a barrier island with 5 miles of beautiful white sandy beaches, no crowds! The majority of the island is a State Park, which you can enjoy at no cost. Whether you want to sit and relax poolside, or on your private gorgeous beach, maybe want to grab a kayak, paddle-board or load up your golf cart, it's days of fun for all. There's plenty of experienced Captains that you can hire for experiencing world class fishing as well. Compared to other places around SW Florida, this place has so much to offer you. This property has also been successful in the rental market and the seller's great management team is ready and willing to continue to work with new owners, should this be an investment/income producing property for you. They'll have the house ready to go with personal grocery shopping, so all you have to do is to start your vacation!

Listing is courtesy of: Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc. (239-322-5680)

Listing Agent: Dalene Westhues (239-443-0936)

Remarks: End Unit With Harbor Views! Experience the ultimate waterfront lifestyle in this Value Priced Townhome with shared Dockage for your Boat. This furnished and decorated property is conveniently located just steps from the dock slips and a short walk from the ferry landing and club restaurant. It is the ideal choice for boating enthusiasts and waterfront living aficionados alike. As a member of Safety Harbor Club, you will enjoy access to a wide range of exceptional amenities, including a club restaurant, heated community pool, and state-of-the-art tennis and pickleball courts. You'll also have private access to the pristine Gulf beaches, where you can bask in the sunshine or take a leisurely stroll with world-class shelling. Don't miss the opportunity to make your dream of waterfront living a reality at a price you can afford!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: This Charming Island-Style retreat offers Beautiful Views of the Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, both being visible from the inviting front porch and the luxurious master bath. Great location on a more highly elevated corner lot bordering the private airstrip and on one of the most picturesque streets on the island. The entire house offers vaulted ceilings and effortless living spaces conveniently on a single level. Step into the fully updated kitchen area with brand-new appliances, including an induction range. The house exterior was improved with brand-new impact windows and doors and a top-of-the-line aluminum standing-seam roof. Relax in the expansive screened in L-shaped porch, strategically designed to capture refreshing breezes from the bay and the gulf, creating an idyllic haven for enjoying the island's natural beauty. Just steps to the white sugar sand beach, this well maintained home could be your perfect retirement and vacation destination!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: An Extremely Special Combination of Location, Privacy, and a Spectacularly Designed Home! Just steps from the beach and backing up to conservation land to the south. With a meandering floorplan, this home offers so much space, melding together tall ceiling spaces, light-filled cupolas, and 3 large bedroom suites, each with its own full bath. The great room offers a large covered screen porch area, soaring cathedral ceilings, abundant windows, plus an open-concept kitchen and dining space. The top-level room is large enough for the whole family to gather, enjoy sunset toasts at the wet bar, and gaze out to magnificent North Captiva Sunsets. That room could also be utilized as an incredible office or 4th king-sized sleeping space. The outdoor living space is maximized with the additional three-story attached lookout tower - one level is for coffee, one for lunch, and one to toast the setting sun. The exterior features mostly impact windows, new Hardie board siding, and a new standing seam roof. The private enclosed elevator from the ground level lands at a beautiful entry porch outside the front foyer. The backyard has plenty of room for a large pool and entertainment area, with extra privacy bordering land owned by the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation. This very valuable and rare lot is perfect for building another dream beach home with an incredible view of the water or to keep for private tropical gardens near the sea... the option is available to make an offer on just the house. A Safety Harbor Club membership for shared BOAT DOCKAGE, heated pool, pickleball & tennis courts is also available. For even more privacy, the adjacent view lot to the west on 4601 Oro Pesos Ln is available for an additional $565k.

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Island Fixer Upper Opportunity that is Priced to Sell Quickly! Lots of house for the money, but you have to be ready to put in the work. Significant Long Term Upside if you add your sweat equity to upgrade this home to meet its full potential. Spacious and well-thought-out floor plan with tall ceilings and gracious entry foyer. Abundant outdoor porch space with Views of the Bay from the upper levels. Well-designed dine-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances, dining bar, and tons of storage space. The large top-level room is a fantastic place to enjoy the evening sunsets, and could be used as a 4th bonus sleeping space. The nicely landscaped lot has room for a large pool area. Brand new aluminum standing seam roof. Listed at the lowest cost per square foot you will see this market cycle on the island!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Island Living at its Finest with Tortuga Sunset, an exquisite Turn-Key ready estate perched gracefully along North Captiva's small airstrip with Unobstructed Views of the Gulf and Direct Access to the Beach!  Everything you have dreamed of for your beach vacation home is here.  Each of the three bedrooms features its own ensuite full bathroom, ensuring privacy and convenience for every guest. The heart of the home is the high-end kitchen, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances, an ice maker, a double oven fueled by propane gas, a built-in griddle, and ample counter space with an island leading to the dining area with impressive views of the airstrip and gulf.  Perfect for culinary enthusiasts and entertaining family and guests! The spacious living area will dazzle you with its TV/media space under soaring cathedral ceilings and its unique clerestory that brings in extra daylight. The saltwater heated pool and hot tub with paver surround is ideal for relaxing in the sun or under the stars. When you've finally had enough sun, the under-home entertainment area includes ping pong, a corn hole, and a great seating area—professionally landscaped with a built-in sprinkler system. If you are a pilot, this home is one of only three homes on the island designed to park a plane under the home. This home is ready to rent from day one and will be a top performer with all its amenities. If you want a turn-key home with a view and great rental potential or are a pilot, this home is a must-see!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Incredible Panoramic Views in multiple directions with your own private Sandy Beach! Spend your days nestling your toes in the sand, jumping into the serene bayside waters, exploring nearby seagrass beds, catching snook from your dock, or heading out for a day on the boat. This unique property includes 1/2 interest in the multifamily bayside dock & lift already in place. The outdoor entertainment opportunities at this property are endless, and it is time for fun in the sun! The exterior of this waterfront bungalow is like new, offering fantastic new upgrades with Hardie board siding, fresh interior and exterior paint, a new standing seam roof, new impact windows & sliding glass doors, new TPO roof deck, and new aluminum railings on both levels. The large waterfront screen porch will be destination #1 when you arrive. With superb bay views, you will relax watching wild dolphins play offshore. Inside offers a full kitchen with large laundry & pantry spaces, panoramic views wrapping around the entire living area, and vaulted ceilings above the dining & living great room. Wake up every morning with a stunning view of the sunrise on the bay! Living the dream and dreaming of the beach, this home has two bedrooms and a sleeping space/ den with beach views through the floor-to-ceiling windows. This home sits on a uniquely situated piece of land that provides views that are unlike any other on the island, with its multi-directions and view down the bayside coastline down to the historic fish house. Don't miss out on all the potential unlimited potential of this property!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: One of a Kind Beachfront Estate Opportunity on North Captiva Island! 4 parcels with the ability to build up to 3 homes. The current house is damaged. You can remodel and shape its floorplan into the beach house of your dreams! Customize the existing 4 sleeping rooms and 4+ baths, with a spacious great room and kitchen on the second level, while the third story has incredible views and can be used as an office, loft, or extra sleeping space for guests. The exceptional panoramic views of the beach, pass and the long scenic shoreline of Cayo Costa will astound you. It is an extraordinary location! Together, the four parcels will all have a perfect private beach, giving this estate package so much potential and flexibility. It is one of the most exciting estate collections ever to be listed on North Captiva!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: Beachfront Hurricane Deal! Unique opportunity to customize your own grand beachfront estate home! Spectacular one-of-a-kind location with exceptional panoramic views of the pass and Cayo Costa. The existing floorplan offers space for 4 sleeping rooms and 4-5 baths, with a spacious great room and kitchen on the second level. The third story has incredible views and can be used as an office, loft, or extra sleeping space. Included with this property is an additional beach parcel bordering the gulf coastline. The adjacent buildable parcels to the north and south are also available for purchase. This property has so much potential to be the beach house you have always dreamed of!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)

Remarks: This Impressive BEACHFRONT Estate Home has every upgrade and amenity you can think of. The land is also extremely valuable, with two lots that combine to make it one of the largest beachfront parcels on the island. The reverse floor plan takes full advantage of the sweeping panorama of surf and sunsets and has plenty of room for all of your family and friends to come to join in the fun. The great room windows highlight the sparkling Gulf waters, while the covered screen porch adds outdoor living space and brings the outside sea breeze in. The top level can be used as an office, den, or very special 5th bedroom. Step outside to the observation deck there and be awed by the breadth of the water view. This home was built and remodeled with all the right materials: Hardie board, impact windows, standing seam metal roof, aluminum railings, ipe stairs, and pool deck, and well-crafted trim. If you are looking for income opportunities, this home has consistently been one of the top echelon rental performers on the island. Don't miss your chance to buy the only Gulf Front home anywhere in this area at this price point!

Listing is courtesy of: Resort Properties Internationa (239-395-2214)

Listing Agent: Mark Muller (239-395-2214)